Thursday 23rd of February 2012 01:10:08 AM
 
 
 
Home

Opinion: An Open letter to the Ambassadors of Donor countries accredited to Uganda

E-mail Print PDF

Your Excellencies, the Ambassadors of the donor countries accredited to Uganda. I write this piece out of dismay by your continuous bullying of Uganda. The recent anti gay bill debate has exposed you as bullies who want Uganda to do as you please.

By assuming the Ugandan parliament is made up of insane goons incapable of reaching a consensus on the anti gay bill, you have demonstrated uttermost disrespect for our legislature. In your own countries, the legislature is a highly revered independent organ of governance above reproach and does not entertain threats or interference from within or without.

Over the last century, your esteemed countries have extolled democracy as the legitimate governance process regardless of cultures and traditions of other societies. There is no doubt, in western societies; democracy is a cherished value that has evolved for hundreds of years and works well, we see and enjoy its fruits. In your engagement policy with Uganda, you should observe the same democratic fundamentals as in your countries, stop dictating what Ugandans should do without considering what Ugandans want for themselves.

During my childhood, the elders in my community taught me the concept of consensus building which unlike democracy, the minority views are understood, respected and integrated making both the majority and minority winners.  Unfortunately, your form of democracy excludes the minority and that is possibly one of the reasons why democracy does not resonate well across Africa.

The systems and nations you represent have suppressed indigenous consensus based societies across Africa resulting into cyclical conflicts. With all due respect, the coercive push for western democracy has cost Africa a lot of blood and laid the foundation for political instability; you have learnt nothing from Africans but expect the later to embrace your ideas and traditions without query.

Your continued threats to cut aid to poor countries when they act independently are opportunistic and undermine the concept of democracy enjoyed in your own countries. Your interference in the Ugandan law making process is unacceptable and does not at all endear you to the Ugandan populace. To the contrary you are stirring up popular resentment that could result in full-scale hostility against the people, systems and values you represent.

If the Ugandan legislature subjected the current anti gay bill to a public vote through a referendum and the public overwhelmingly votes against your wishes, would you then punish the entire population because of voting against your wishes?

Your choice of engagement on the anti gay bill reveals double standards. You unashamedly roll out red carpets and dine with rulers like the Saudi Royals who rule over governments that have trampled on women’s and minority rights and have no respect for democracy but threaten poor countries for engaging in debates you don’t approve.

You ‘preach what you do not practice’, in your own countries, you have laws that do not uphold human rights for example capital offence in the USA. In most of Europe, families don’t have the right to use any weapon to defend themselves in their own homes against aggressive intruders. The minority Muslims section of your populace cannot freely practice some aspects of their religion like polygamy. Are these groups not minorities whose rights should also be upheld like the gay people? Has any other country admonished or demanded that you change your laws and values to comply with their wishes?

There is no doubt a section of Ugandans believe the anti gay bill requires amendments before it is turned into a law. You should have some iota of trust in the Ugandan legislative assembly to make good none repressive laws that uphold the Ugandan values and human rights.  Bullying an entire country and its government because you are unhappy about a specific bill under debate defies the logic of democracy you stand for and portrays your governments and values as despotic towards the poor countries that refuse to dance to your tune even when your fiddle is out of tune.

Uganda being poor does not licence your countries to dictate which bills should be debated in her parliament. Let Uganda be, ‘the winds that blow will determine which leaf on the tree will be the next to go.’ If you truly want to nurture democracy, refrain from coercion and arm twisting, it is against the democratic principles that you represent.

Whereas I abhor the anti gay bill in its current form because of its implications on the minority, I disagree with your approach, stripping Uganda of her dignity and the shredding of the basic tenets of democracy. I strongly believe in the independence of the legislature and the principle of sovereignty.

For God and My Country

Joseph K Kamara, [mailto:
 This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it
 ] 

 

Comments (14)Add Comment
What in the name of all that is sane is this garbage?
written by Mbukuuli ya Buganda, January 28, 2010
Which part of Conditional Funding/AID does this guy not understand? There are numerous countries that were pillaged to a greater degree than yours that are now independent in mind, deed and pocket. If you want to be self determining then get on with it. Stop asking others to do it for you or for their permission. Until you start managing your resources responsibly, you will continue to get out the vaseline, bend over, steady yourself, with the gays you so fear only too happy to oblige you, and you learning to like it. Watch and learn from Haiti, literally and figuratively buggered after 200 years of so-called independence, and they will learn to love it. The above article is a despicable insult to all self respecting Africans.
What in the name of all that is sane is this garbage?
written by Mbukuuli ya Buganda, January 28, 2010
Which part of Conditional Funding/AID does this guy not understand? There are numerous countries that were pillaged to a greater degree than yours that are now independent in mind, deed and pocket. If you want to be self determining then get on with it. Stop asking others to do it for you or for their permission. Until you start managing your resources responsibly, you will continue to get out the vaseline, bend over, steady yourself, with the gays you so fear only too happy to oblige you, and you learning to like it. Watch and learn from Haiti, literally and figuratively buggered after 200 years of so-called independence, and they will learn to love it. The above article is a despicable insult to all self respecting Africans.
...
written by Lynn David, January 28, 2010
Originally, the voices of decent from Europe and America have been from Christian voices. Many, such as the ministry Exodus International, spoke out against the bill saying that life and liberty were not appropriate Christian responses to homosexuality; and further that criminalization stands against the redemptive message of Christ and the love and compassion of Christ for all. Indeed, even the Catholic Church in Uganda has stated their opposition to the bill; and that is the policy of vatican for that very reason. It is in that same vein that the Christian leaders of many governments have continued their opposition.
...
written by Lynn David, January 28, 2010
And as to democracy. What sort of democratic government would create a bill denying scientific terms based in human psychology with the express purpose of denying freedom of speech to a class of people?
Independence
written by Fighter, January 28, 2010
Joseph, your letter is irrelevant. If you believe that the country is independent, then why do you need the aid? The government itself is a liability to it's own people. How will stop being a liability to foreign governments? Remember, the aid is part of the money being embezzled in this country. Therefore, government needs it more than anyone else does.
Sodomy and Aids for Africa
written by Gowon, January 29, 2010
Each time Ugandans demand for freedom of expression and independence to debate pertinent issue affecting their life negatively, should this fly in the face of some western homosexual bullies, self-imposing homosexual goon threatens withdrawal of donor aids money.
First we don not want homosexual tax money if we could split it out from the heterosexual tax money. Since we cannot do that, homosexual please do not pay taxes to government which gives aids to Uganda. Majority heterosexuals in the west are only too willing to pay taxes that can be used as aids money for Uganda; and this we know for truth. Secondly Ugandans never ask for donor money, but donors thrust it down our throat. The last thing they should do is thrust it for sodomy.
Chuntering stupidity
written by Omeros, January 31, 2010
What vain nonsense Kamara speaks. The person who has done most to retard democratic progress in Uganda is he who for a decade and a half proscribed political parties from participating in public life, the same man who altered the constitution to permit himself to stay in the office of president indefinitely (which end he engineered by bribing each parliamentarian the sum of 5m/=). The chief enemy of democracy in Uganda is the man who twice directed that mambas be stationed outside the courts of judicature to carry out arrests of citizens lawfully bailed in disobedience of an order of the civil court.
Yet more chuntering stupidity
written by Omeros, January 31, 2010
Democracy's antagonist is he who considers that freedom of association does not extend to the ranks of the opposition whose rallies he orders to be dispersed with teargas whenever and wherever they should occur. The person most contemptuous of democracy is he who shuts down media organisations with whose editorial line he disagrees. The person who fears and so stifles the work of democracy is he whose idea of fair electoral competition involves jailing his opponent for the duration of the presidential campaign, rigging the poll and claiming victory.
Still more chunterinig stupidity
written by Omeros, January 31, 2010
How dare you, Kamara, seek to traduce the donors for undermining the democracy that our very own head of state and his morally bankrupt cohorts in the NRM have never respected.
Homosexual are suicides
written by Lakwena, February 01, 2010
Mr. Joseph K Kamara, you threw a pearl before swines: they would not know what to do with it. In principal you made an excellent argument, but unfortunately Mbukuuli ya Buganda, and Omeros misunderstood or lack the capacity to comprehend the rationale. What does the West and homosexuals want? They are like suicides; they harm themselves, but not without injuring others' feelings, with their stupidity (hoops- sexual disorder). For example what pain do homosexuals' parents and relatives go through? Having a sick child in the home is not a beer party.
Facile, Lakwena
written by Omeros, February 01, 2010
Lakwena, it is a little rich to complain that donors are chipping away at Uganda's parliamentary sovereignty and very democratic system of governance when our leaders routinely fail to recognise such fundamental democratic principles as the separation of powers, limited government and equality before the law. You have a penchant for citing the Good Book. Try this one: "thou hypocrite: first cast out the beam out of thine own eye; and then shalt thou see clearly to cast out the mote out of thy brother's eye".
...
written by Lakwena, February 02, 2010
Omeros, you are directing your bile at the wrong target. If your misunderstanding is my hypocrisy I can live with that. I am not the one who complained that donors are chipping away at Uganda's parliamentary sovereignty and very democratic system. Mr. Kamara was arguing about the logic of sovereignty and the separation of powers; as practiced by the donor countries (sic) development partners, vis-à-vis ours. Just because the current regime does not live by the principle of separation of powers; may I ask your opinion; is it in order for the donors to dictate or interfere with what our parliamentary debates? Why don't they mind their own businesses? You are defending the worst hypocrites (worst violator of human rights in history).
Only and fool can beg and expect to dictate the terms of what they get
written by mbukuuli ya buganda, February 02, 2010
Writing a pleading letter to the messengers of countries who recognise homosexuals as equal citizens is like pushing a bolder up Elgon. If Ugandans cannot see that the path to self determination is one of our own making then we are doomed. There is no intellectualism and certainly no pearl in trying to project your self inflicted incontinence onto others. Even Mugabe has seen the futility of ranting about "Tony Blair and his gay gangsters" whilst simultaneously begging from these same gay gangsters. The end result is that someone will get buggered as Mugabe and Zimbabweans have found out. It is a childish letter of no consequence to the "gay gangsters" nor to Ugandans. It is a vainglorious attempt to put lipstick on a pig/swine.
Lakwena
written by Omeros, February 02, 2010
Frankly, the donors do have a right to tell us what to do. We take their money. It's their taxpayers who foot the bill. It is courtesy of them that we have anything to call a democracy at all. They are the enablers and the guarantors of our state. If they don't like what we do, they are perfectly entilted to withdraw their support. I would have thought that that was a simple fact of economic, still more political, life. If you are less incensed by the daily assaults on the rule of law by our president than the behaviour of donors, I put it to you that your priorities are somewhat misplaced.

Write comment

busy
 
 
 

Podcasts

Videos

You need Flash player 6+ and JavaScript enabled to view this video.




RECOMMENDED

Society
Magical moments Sebunjo, Ismaël Lo make the case for good African music There were a number of magical moments at the World Music showcase by Joel Sebunjo and Ismaël Lo in Kampala in late January. One was watching...
 

MOST READ

LATEST COMMENTS

mtfashley Says:
2012-02-22 14:16:07
ÿþT

Afedra Robert Iga Says:
2012-02-19 10:34:50
If only unhealthy political propaganda can be left out of such benefiting projects like stepping up the face of the city, then all will be good for Ugandans in a very short time. My full support for K

 
Joomla Templates and Joomla Extensions by JoomlaVision.Com

°C

Humidity: 0%

POLL

After those ministers have resigned should MPs now target Museveni?
 
ON THE SHELVES
Banner
 

Cover: Trouble at National Water, corporation sinking as star manager faces probe.

News AnalysisAfter charging Agaba and Komakech with murder, will KCCA be able to bite again?

BusinessNBL sinks Shs 190 bn in new beer plant.


Name:

Email:

COMMENT
The economics and politics of Kampala city traders strike The greatest paradox is that 20 years after privatisation, the traders want the government’s assistance in businesses ...
 
 
 
 
Copyright © 2012 The Independent: You get the truth We Pay the Price. All Rights Reserved.